Three states of equilibrium
Draw a vertical line through the centre of gravity G of a body resting on a support. If that line passes through the support, the weight (down) and the normal reaction (up) act along it, so there is no resultant force and no torque: both conditions of equilibrium are met. The state of equilibrium depends on what happens after a slight tilt.
Stable equilibrium: after a slight tilt, the body comes back to its original position.
Take a cone standing on its wide base and tilt it a little, so that it rests on one edge of the base. G rises. The upward reaction now acts at that edge, while the weight still acts down at G: two unlike parallel forces that are no longer in line. Because the vertical line through G is still inside the base, their torque pulls the cone back down onto its base. Any tilt that keeps this line inside the base ends the same way.
Unstable equilibrium: after a slight tilt, the body moves further away from its original position.
Balance the same cone on its sharp tip. The smallest tilt lowers G, and the line of action of the weight passes outside the tiny point of support. The torque of the weight turns the cone further over, and it falls.
Neutral equilibrium: after being moved, the body stays at rest in its new position.
Roll a cylinder lying on its side across a level table. G keeps the same height, and the weight and the reaction stay in one vertical line, so no torque acts. A football on flat ground and a cone lying on its curved side are neutral too.
| State | After a slight tilt | Height of G | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stable | Returns | Rises | Cone on its base |
| Unstable | Moves further away | Falls | Cone on its tip |
| Neutral | Stays in its new position | Unchanged | Cylinder on its side |
Improving stability
A body is more stable when its centre of gravity is lower and its base is wider. Either change means it must tilt further before the vertical line through G leaves the base.
- A low wooden peerhi is much harder to topple than a tall stool.
- A van with heavy luggage on its roof has a raised G and can roll over on a sharp bend. Ships and double-decker buses keep their heavy parts low for the same reason.
- A chair rocked back on its two rear legs is unstable: lean a little more and G passes behind them, so the weight and the reaction form a couple that tips it backwards.
- Racing cars are built very low, with their wheels set out beyond the body, so G is low and the base is wide.
- Balancing toys have heavy weights hanging below the pivot, so G is under the point of support. Any tilt raises G, and the toy swings back.
Worked numerical: an almirah tilted onto its edge
An 80 kg almirah is tilted forward onto its front edge and released. Take .
(a) The vertical line through G is 0.20 m behind the front edge. Find the torque of the weight about that edge.
The line through G is still over the base, so this torque turns the almirah back: it is stable.
(b) It is tipped further, until that line lies 0.05 m in front of the edge.
This smaller torque acts the other way and topples the almirah.
Using the simulation
In the simulation above, choose Equilibrium under Experiment. The Stable set-up shows a cone on its base, with G 9.0 cm above the table.
- In the bar under the stage, press Tip. The cone leans 15° and G rises to 11.8 cm. Press Let go and it settles back.
- Press Tip four times, then Let go. The vertical line through G now falls outside the base, so the cone falls. Press Reset.
- Choose Unstable, press Tip, then Let go: the cone falls and G drops from 27.0 cm to 8.5 cm.
- Choose Neutral and press Tip. The cylinder rolls, but G stays at 11.0 cm.
Now open Tilt test. The Bookcase has its books on the Bottom shelf, and its critical angle (the tilt at which it starts to topple) is 26.57°. Press Tilt: the platform rises until the bookcase begins to tip at 26.57°. Choose Top shelf, which stands it up on a level platform. Now G sits 1.3 m up instead of 0.5 m, and the critical angle drops to 10.89°. The critical-angle formula is beyond your course; use it only to compare.