Skip to content

GCSE Physics — AQA · Working scientifically

Accuracy, precision and errors

WS 2.7WS 3.7

AQA Working Scientifically (WS 2.7, WS 3.7) on judging data. Accurate means near the true value; precise means repeats bunch tightly. A mean cuts random error but never a systematic one such as a zero error. Quote a result as mean ± half the range. Both tiers.

Loading simulation…

Symbols match your course. Open the full accuracy, precision and errors simulation for more presets and teacher tools.

What AQA expects (WS 2.7 and WS 3.7)

These skills are examined on both tiers, in Physics and Combined Science, usually within a required practical. No equation is involved. Be ready to:

  • judge data as accurate, precise, repeatable or reproducible
  • name sources of random and systematic error, and reduce them
  • find a mean, range and uncertainty (WS 3.3 and WS 3.4)
  • deal with anomalies (WS 3.7) and improve a method (WS 2.7)

The words to use

WordWhat it means
True valueWhat an error-free measurement would give; a data-book value usually stands in for it.
AccurateNear the true value.
PreciseRepeats bunch tightly, wherever the true value is.
RepeatableThe same investigator, method and equipment give similar results again.
ReproducibleResults still agree when another investigator repeats the work with different equipment, or when a different method is used.
AnomalyA result that breaks the pattern set by the rest.

Resolution and zero error are general terms, not defined in the specification, but questions use them. Resolution is the smallest step by which a reading can change: 0.01 s on a stopwatch showing 12.47 s. A zero error is a reading that is not zero when nothing is being measured. Fine resolution is no guarantee of accuracy: a thermometer showing tenths of a degree can still read 2 °C high.

Random and systematic errors

Random errors scatter repeats unpredictably, some high and some low: reaction time on a stopwatch, a flickering display, a draught over a balance. They spoil precision. In a mean of more readings, the highs and lows partly cancel.

Systematic errors shift every reading away from the true value by the same amount: a zero error, a thermometer that reads high, always viewing a scale from above. Data can then be precise yet inaccurate, and repeating cannot help: find the cause and correct for it.

Worked example 1: two zero errors

(a) An empty digital balance shows 0.06 g. A brass mass then reads 50.36 g.

corrected reading=50.36−0.06=50.30 g\text{corrected reading} = 50.36 - 0.06 = 50.30\ \text{g}

(b) Before switch-on, an ammeter needle rests at −0.04 A. With current flowing it shows 0.48 A.

corrected reading=0.48−(−0.04)=0.52 A\text{corrected reading} = 0.48 - (-0.04) = 0.52\ \text{A}

Subtracting a negative zero error adds it on. Better still, zero the instrument first.

Mean, range and uncertainty

WS 3.4 treats every measurement as uncertain, judging how much from the spread of the repeats about their mean. Write the result as mean ± half the range.

Worked example 2: a falling paper cone

A paper cone dropped from 1.50 m is timed five times: 1.26 s, 1.18 s, 1.21 s, 1.63 s and 1.23 s.

Anomaly: 1.63 s. The notes say the cone clipped a stool, a poor measurement, so it is ignored.

mean=1.26+1.18+1.21+1.234=4.884=1.22 s\text{mean} = \frac{1.26 + 1.18 + 1.21 + 1.23}{4} = \frac{4.88}{4} = 1.22\ \text{s}

Range: 1.26−1.18=0.081.26 - 1.18 = 0.08 s. Uncertainty: 0.08÷2=0.040.08 \div 2 = 0.04 s. Result: 1.22±0.041.22 \pm 0.04 s.

Keeping 1.63 s would give a mean of 1.30 s and a range of 0.45 s. With no known cause, repeat the drop rather than delete the value.

Evaluating a method (WS 2.7)

  • Enough readings? Repeats at each value, over a wide range.
  • Precise enough? A wide spread means random error; light gates or a data logger remove reaction time.
  • Systematic error? Look for results all high or all low against an accepted value, or a line missing the origin when it should pass through it.
  • Valid? The method answers the question, with control variables fixed.

Using the simulation

In the simulation above, five shots from a steady shooter open the Target view, labelled Accurate and precise.

  1. In the set-up menu beside Clear, swap Both for Precise only. The new group is tight but off-centre: Accuracy gets a cross, Precision a tick. Drag Sight offset to 0 and the group slides home unchanged.
  2. Choose Readings and press Read 5. The ruler's worn end adds 2 mm, so the 86.6 mm pencil reads 88 or 89 mm. Press Read 5 three more times: Mean − true value stays near +2 mm. Drag Zero error (worn end) to 0 and it drops to 0.0 mm.
  3. Switch on Include an odd reading (number 4). Keep it is chosen first; try Leave out and Repeat it, watching Range and Uncertainty (½ range).
  4. Choose Resolution and press Measure. A ball 12.374 mm across reads 13 mm (ruler), 12.6 mm (Vernier callipers) and 12.57 mm (micrometer): all too big, because of a shared +0.20 mm zero error. Drag the zero error slider to 0 to see 12 mm, 12.4 mm and 12.37 mm.

On a phone, sliders are in the Controls tab below the stage, cards in the Readings tab.

Common mistakes

  • Using precise when you mean accurate. Repeat readings can agree with each other perfectly and still all be wrong by the same amount, because of a systematic error.
  • Calling a result reproducible when the same person simply did it again. That is repeatable. AQA's reproducible needs a different investigator using different equipment, or a different method.
  • Giving the whole range as the uncertainty. Halve the range and write the result as the mean ± that value.
  • Crossing out an anomaly without a reason. Look for what caused it first, ignore it only if it came from a poor measurement, and say why.
  • Expecting extra repeats to fix a zero error. Averaging cuts down random error only; subtract the zero error or reset the instrument to zero.
  • Assuming that an instrument with a fine resolution must be accurate. A digital meter showing many decimal places can still be badly calibrated.

Exam-style questions

Original questions written in the style of GCSE AQA. Try each one before you reveal the answer.

  1. 1.A student times how long a paper helicopter takes to fall 2.00 m. The five repeat timings are 2.14 s, 2.06 s, 2.11 s, 2.60 s and 2.09 s.

    1. (a)Which result is anomalous?

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: 2.60 s

      Marking points

      • 2.60 s
    2. (b)The student's notes say that the helicopter brushed against a cupboard during that drop. What should the student do with the anomalous result? Give a reason.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Ignore it (leave it out of the mean), or repeat that drop, because it came from a poor measurement: the fall was interrupted.

      Marking points

      • Ignore it / leave it out of the mean (allow: repeat that drop)
      • It came from a poor measurement, as the helicopter's fall was interrupted
    3. (c)Calculate the mean time. Do not include the anomalous result.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Mean = (2.14 + 2.06 + 2.11 + 2.09) ÷ 4 = 8.40 ÷ 4 = 2.10 s

      Marking points

      • 8.40 ÷ 4
      • 2.10 s (allow 2.1 s)
    4. (d)Calculate the uncertainty in the mean time.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Range = 2.14 − 2.06 = 0.08 s. Uncertainty = half the range = ± 0.04 s.

      Marking points

      • Range = 2.14 − 2.06 = 0.08 s
      • Uncertainty = ± 0.04 s
    5. (e)Suggest one change to the method that would reduce the random error caused by the student's reaction time.

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: Use light gates and a data logger (or film the fall and time it frame by frame) instead of a hand-operated stopwatch.

      Marking points

      • Light gates / a data logger / video analysis instead of a hand-held stopwatch
  2. 2.Two students, A and B, each do the specific heat capacity required practical with the same aluminium block. The accepted value for aluminium is 900 J/kg °C. Student A's three values are 1240, 1250 and 1245 J/kg °C. Student B's three values are 840, 960 and 905 J/kg °C.

    1. (a)Whose results are more precise? Give a reason.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Student A. A's three values lie within 10 J/kg °C of one another, while B's are spread over 120 J/kg °C.

      Marking points

      • Student A
      • A's values are much closer together (range 10 J/kg °C compared with 120 J/kg °C)
    2. (b)Whose mean is more accurate? Give a reason.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Student B. B's mean is about 902 J/kg °C, very close to 900 J/kg °C, but A's mean is 1245 J/kg °C.

      Marking points

      • Student B
      • B's mean (about 902 J/kg °C) is much nearer the accepted value than A's (1245 J/kg °C)
    3. (c)Every one of Student A's values is about 350 J/kg °C too high. Suggest a cause of this error and how it could be reduced.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Energy was transferred from the block to the surroundings, so the block warmed up less than expected, which makes each calculated value too high. Wrap the block in insulation.

      Marking points

      • Energy lost to the surroundings (block not insulated), so the block warmed up too little. Also accept: poor thermal contact between the thermometer and the block, so the measured temperature rise is too small
      • Insulate the block, e.g. wrap it in cotton wool or bubble wrap (or, for poor contact, put a little oil or water in the thermometer hole)
    4. (d)Explain why Student A would not get a more accurate mean by taking more repeat readings.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: This is a systematic error: it pushes every value too high by a similar amount. Averaging more values only reduces the effect of random error, so the mean would still be about 350 J/kg °C too high.

      Marking points

      • The error is systematic: every value is too high by about the same amount
      • Averaging reduces only random error, so the mean stays about 350 J/kg °C too high
  3. 3.A student investigates how the current through a filament lamp depends on the potential difference across it. Before the circuit is switched on, the needle of the ammeter points to −0.02 A.

    1. (a)Name this type of error.

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: A zero error, which is a kind of systematic error.

      Marking points

      • Zero error (allow systematic error)
    2. (b)Will the uncorrected current readings be too high or too low? Give a reason.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Too low. The needle starts 0.02 A below zero, so every reading is 0.02 A less than the true current.

      Marking points

      • Too low
      • The needle starts from −0.02 A, so each reading is 0.02 A below the true current
    3. (c)The ammeter reads 0.34 A when the potential difference is 6.0 V. Calculate the true current.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: True current = 0.34 − (−0.02) = 0.36 A

      Marking points

      • 0.34 − (−0.02) or 0.34 + 0.02
      • 0.36 A
    4. (d)A student at another school repeats the investigation with different apparatus and gets similar results. Are the results repeatable or reproducible? Give a reason.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Reproducible, because a different investigator using different equipment obtained similar results.

      Marking points

      • Reproducible
      • A different investigator with different equipment got similar results
  4. 4.A student has two thermometers. Thermometer P is a liquid-in-glass thermometer marked every 1 °C. Thermometer Q is digital and shows temperatures to 0.1 °C.

    1. (a)Give the resolution of thermometer Q.

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: 0.1 °C

      Marking points

      • 0.1 °C
    2. (b)Both thermometers are put into melting ice, which is at 0 °C. P reads 0 °C and Q reads 1.4 °C. Explain why Q gives less accurate readings than P even though its resolution is better.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Q has a systematic (zero) error: it reads 1.4 °C above the true value. Resolution is only the smallest change Q can show; it does not bring the readings closer to the true value.

      Marking points

      • Q reads 1.4 °C above the true value (a zero / systematic error)
      • Better resolution only means smaller changes can be shown; it does not make readings closer to the true value
    3. (c)Q then reads 37.9 °C in a beaker of warm water. Assume its error is the same at all temperatures. Calculate the corrected temperature.

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: 37.9 − 1.4 = 36.5 °C

      Marking points

      • 36.5 °C

Quick check

6 questions

  1. 1.Which statement describes reproducible results, in the sense AQA uses?
  2. 2.Five readings of a potential difference are 3.42 V, 3.48 V, 3.45 V, 3.44 V and 3.46 V. What is the uncertainty in their mean?
  3. 3.A student's reaction time changes each time a stopwatch is started and stopped. How can its effect on the final result be reduced?
  4. 4.With no load attached, a newtonmeter's pointer sits at −0.2 N. With a load hanging from it, the newtonmeter reads 3.6 N. What is the true weight of the load?
  5. 5.A length is measured four times: 52.1 cm, 52.0 cm, 52.1 cm and 52.0 cm. Its true value is 50.0 cm. How are the readings best described?
  6. 6.What is the resolution of a stopwatch whose display shows 14.36 s?