What AQA expects (AT 1 and WS 2.6)
Measuring skills are assessed on both tiers, in GCSE Physics and in Combined Science. There is no equation to learn. Questions built around the required practicals expect you to:
- pick suitable apparatus for a measurement and justify your choice
- read a scale and record the value properly, with its unit
- judge results in terms of accuracy, precision and error, and use repeat readings to estimate an uncertainty.
For Required practical 5 on density (Combined Science numbers it differently), the specification gives a ruler, a micrometer or Vernier callipers as examples of apparatus for measuring an object's sizes. It names these instruments but does not describe their scales, so reading a vernier is useful practice rather than a listed requirement.
Resolution
The resolution of an instrument is the smallest change in the quantity being measured that makes its reading change. Exam questions often ask for it. A digital balance that shows 34.27 g has a resolution of 0.01 g.
| Instrument | Usual resolution | Sensible job |
|---|---|---|
| Ruler or metre rule | 1 mm | a block a few centimetres long |
| Vernier callipers | 0.1 mm (0.01 cm) | a coin, a marble or a short rod |
| Micrometer | 0.01 mm | a wire or a sheet of card |
Choose a resolution that is tiny compared with the length itself. Being 1 mm out hardly matters on a 30 cm plank, but it is half of a 2 mm wire.
Reading Vernier callipers
Close the jaws gently on the object. Find the zero on the sliding vernier scale and note the last millimetre mark on the main scale that it has passed: the main scale reading. Then find the one vernier line that sits exactly on a main-scale mark. Each vernier division adds 0.1 mm.
Worked example 1: a steel ball bearing. The vernier zero has passed the 1.7 cm mark, and vernier line 4 lines up.
Given: main scale reading cm, line 4, each division cm. Working: . Answer: cm. Always record to 0.01 cm: if line 0 had lined up, the reading would be 1.70 cm, not 1.7 cm.
With the jaws closed on nothing, these callipers show +0.03 cm instead of zero. This zero error adds the same amount to every reading, so it is a systematic error. Corrected reading = observed reading − zero error cm. A negative zero error is therefore added on.
Accuracy, precision and uncertainty
- A measurement is accurate when it is close to the true value.
- Measurements are precise when repeat readings cluster tightly together.
- Random errors scatter readings unpredictably. Take several readings and work out a mean.
- Systematic errors, such as a zero error, shift every reading by the same amount. Repeating cannot remove them; find the cause and correct for it.
So an uncorrected zero error can give readings that are precise yet inaccurate.
Worked example 2: mean and uncertainty. A student measures the diameter of a marble five times: 1.62 cm, 1.66 cm, 1.64 cm, 1.63 cm and 1.65 cm.
Mean: cm. Range: cm. Uncertainty: half the range, cm. Result: cm.
Using the simulation
In the simulation above, the outside jaws start closed on the Brass cylinder. The Main scale reading card shows 2.3 cm, Vernier division in line shows 6 and Least count shows 0.01 cm. Least count is the smallest step this scale can show, so here it is the resolution. The Reading card gives 2.36 cm, or 23.6 mm if you choose mm under Show lengths in.
Press Positive under Zero error. Its size starts at 0.03 cm, so Observed reading jumps to 2.39 cm while Corrected reading stays at 2.36 cm. Try Negative and watch the observed value drop below the true one.
Then choose Practice under Mode. Press Check zero to read any zero error, press Back, type the true size and press Check. New sets another task.
For very thin objects, open the micrometer screw gauge simulation, which reads to 0.01 mm.