Skip to content

Measurement and skills simulation

Accuracy and Precision Simulation

Shots on an archery target show sets that are accurate, precise, both or neither. The same ideas then turn into real repeat readings from a worn ruler, a badly calibrated thermometer and a late stopwatch, with means, ranges, an odd reading and three instruments of different resolution.

Loading simulation…
Show symbols for

Predict first

Question 1 of 3

The first 2 mm of a ruler have worn away, so it has a zero error of +2 mm. A pencil is really 86.6 mm long. You measure it 20 times instead of 5 and find the mean. Where does the mean end up?

Try this

  1. 1On the Target view, press Fire 5 twice. Watch the orange cross (the mean) and the shaded circle (the spread) settle as each shot lands. Does the label above the gauges change?
  2. 2Drag the Sight offset slider from 0 to 9 cm. The same shots slide across together without changing shape. Which gauge now shows a red cross instead of a green tick, Accuracy or Precision?
  3. 3Choose Readings. The ruler starts with a zero error of +2 mm. Press Read 5 until you have 20 readings, then compare the Mean card with the True value card.
  4. 4In Readings, switch on Include an odd reading (number 4) and press Read 5. Try Keep it, Leave out and Repeat it in turn. Each time, watch the orange mean line and the shaded band, mean ± half the range, on the plot.
  5. 5Choose Resolution and press Measure. Then drag the zero error slider slowly. Which band moves in the biggest jumps? Set it to 0 and check which band is narrowest.

What this simulation shows

This simulation builds up accuracy and precision in three steps. First you fire at an archery target whose centre stands for the true value. Next the same ideas become real repeat readings, taken with a ruler, a thermometer or a stopwatch. Last, one steel ball is measured on three instruments with very different resolutions. Every number on screen comes from the same model as the picture, so the cards, the dots and the shots always agree.

The target view

Two sliders control the shooter. Sight offset is a systematic error: a knocked sight moves every shot the same distance in the same direction. Scatter is a random error: shaky hands send each shot a different way. The orange cross marks the mean position of the shots, and the shaded circle shows their average distance from it.

Here a set counts as accurate when its mean lies inside the gold, within 4 cm of the centre, and as precise when the shots sit on average within 2 cm of their own mean. Drag the offset and the whole group slides without changing shape. Drag the scatter and the group swells or shrinks around the point the sight aims at.

Real readings

In the Readings view, each press of Read records one measurement, rounded to the step the instrument can be read to. The ruler has lost its first 2 mm, so a pencil laid against its end always reads long. The thermometer reads 1.5 °C too high. The stopwatch is stopped a moment after the toy car hits the end of its ramp.

Watch the Mean card as the readings pile up. Random scatter largely cancels, so the mean steadies, but it steadies on the dashed line, the true value plus the systematic error, and never on the green true-value line. Only finding the cause and correcting it closes that gap. The range and half the range describe the spread, and half the range gives an estimate of the uncertainty.

Resolution is not accuracy

In the Resolution view, press Measure to read a ball 12.374 mm across with a ruler (1 mm), vernier callipers (0.1 mm) and a micrometer (0.01 mm). The shaded band on each row holds every length that would produce that reading, so a finer instrument has a narrower band. Give all three the same zero error and each band moves in jumps of its own size. Every band still holds the true value plus the error, but once the error is big enough, none of them holds the true value itself. Extra digits never cancel a systematic error.

When one reading does not fit

Switch on the odd reading and reading 4 lands far from the rest, with a note saying what went wrong. Keeping it drags the mean towards it and stretches the range. Leaving it out is fine when you can state the reason, and repeating the measurement is better still. A reading should never disappear just because it spoils a result.

Your course's words

AQA and Cambridge use precise to mean that repeat readings agree closely, although Cambridge also speaks of an instrument's precision when it tells you how many decimal places to record. The Punjab Class 9 book uses the first meaning for its target picture, but it also ties precision to the instrument, so a screw gauge reading counts as more precise than a metre rule reading. It links accuracy to fractional uncertainty too. Cambridge asks you to judge a reading between two marks to the nearest half division, which this sim does for the thermometer while the ruler is read to the nearest millimetre, and it gives a range as its lowest and highest values. With the Punjab course chosen, a mean that ends exactly in 5 is rounded to the even digit, as the book does in section 1.13. Choose a course in the symbol switcher to see its own terms in the Key words box, along with where they come from.

Check your understanding

8 questions

  1. 1.Five arrows land in a tight group about 6 cm to the left of the bullseye. How is the set best described?
  2. 2.The worn end of a ruler makes every reading 2 mm too long. What happens if you take ten readings instead of three?
  3. 3.A student times one swing four times: 2.31 s, 2.27 s, 2.35 s and 2.29 s. What is the uncertainty, taken as half the range?
  4. 4.What does the resolution of a measuring instrument describe?
  5. 5.Which of these reduces the effect of random error on a final result?
  6. 6.A micrometer reads to 0.01 mm but has a zero error of +0.05 mm. Which statement is true?
  7. 7.One reading is far from the rest, and your notes say the ruler slipped. What should you do with it?
  8. 8.In the Punjab Class 9 book's sense, which instrument gives the most precise single measurement of a wire's diameter?

For teachers

Embed it in your site or open it full-screen for the projector.

Read more