Skip to content

Punjab Board Class 9 Physics · Physical quantities and measurements

Errors and uncertainty in measurements

Section 1.9Section 1.10

Section 1.9 names three kinds of error: human (personal), systematic (zero error, poor calibration, wrong marking) and random, each reduced in its own way. Section 1.10: no measurement is exact, and a scale reading is uncertain by ± half the least count, ±0.05 cm on a millimetre scale.

Loading simulation…

Symbols match your course. Open the full accuracy, precision and errors simulation for more presets and teacher tools.

Sections 1.9 and 1.10 in brief

No measurement is perfect. Section 1.9 sorts errors into three kinds, each reduced in its own way, and section 1.10 states how uncertain a reading is. Precision, accuracy and rounding off (1.12 and 1.13) have their own Precision and accuracy page.

Three kinds of error (1.9)

ErrorWhere it comes fromHow to reduce it
Human (personal)The observer: misjudging a pointer between two marks, an eye not straight in front of the mark, a wrong reading method, or slow reactions with a stopwatchTraining, careful technique and no distractions; best of all, automatic or digital instruments
SystematicA fault that changes every reading by the same amount: a zero error, poor calibration or wrong marking of the scaleCompare the instrument with a more accurate one, then apply a correction to each reading
RandomUnpredictable changes the observer cannot control, such as a draught, or small changes in humidity, room temperature or the mains voltage, so repeated readings differTake several readings and use their mean

A mean of many readings cannot cancel a systematic error, because every reading carries the same shift.

Worked numerical 1: a worn metre rule

The first 3 mm of a metre rule have worn away, so its end now sits at the 0.3 cm position. A pencil laid against that end reaches the 15.8 cm mark.

zero error=+0.3 cmlength=15.8 cm−0.3 cm=15.5 cm\text{zero error} = +0.3\ \text{cm} \qquad \text{length} = 15.8\ \text{cm} - 0.3\ \text{cm} = 15.5\ \text{cm}

Safer still, avoid the worn end: start the pencil at a clear mark such as 1.0 cm. With the tip at 16.5 cm, the length is again 16.5−1.0=15.516.5 - 1.0 = 15.5 cm.

Uncertainty in one reading (1.10)

Every measured value is uncertain: a scale shows nothing finer than its least count, its smallest division. Only counting, such as the bricks in a pile, is exact.

Your book reads a scale using the midpoint of a division. If the end of the object stops short of halfway between two marks, record the lower mark; if it reaches or passes halfway, record the higher one. Either way, the true end lies within half a division of the recorded mark:

uncertainty=±12×least count\text{uncertainty} = \pm\tfrac{1}{2} \times \text{least count}

Worked numerical 2: the halfway rule

A wire's end lies between the 12.6 cm and 12.7 cm marks of a metre rule, whose least count is 0.1 cm.

  • If it stops before 12.65 cm, record 12.6 cm.
  • If it reaches or passes 12.65 cm, record 12.7 cm.
uncertainty=12×0.1 cm=0.05 cm\text{uncertainty} = \tfrac{1}{2} \times 0.1\ \text{cm} = 0.05\ \text{cm}

So the first reading is written 12.6±0.0512.6 \pm 0.05 cm. The same rule gives ±0.005 cm on Vernier Callipers and ±0.005 mm on a screw gauge. On a digital display the last digit may flicker; Table 1.7 rates a digital stopwatch at ±0.01 s and an analogue one at ±0.1 s.

Worked numerical 3: thirty swings

Section 1.10 adds that repeating and averaging shrinks the uncertainty of short times and small lengths. A student times 30 oscillations of a pendulum: 48.6 s, uncertain by about ±0.2 s because of reaction time at the start and the stop.

T=48.6 s30=1.62 sT = \frac{48.6\ \text{s}}{30} = 1.62\ \text{s} uncertainty in T=0.2 s30≈0.007 s\text{uncertainty in } T = \frac{0.2\ \text{s}}{30} \approx 0.007\ \text{s}

Timing a single swing would leave the whole ±0.2 s on a reading of about 1.6 s.

Using the simulation

In the simulation above, switch to Readings. The Ruler is set up, and no readings have been taken yet.

  1. Press Read 5. Its worn end gives this ruler a zero error of +2 mm: every reading of the 86.6 mm pencil comes out at 88 or 89 mm, and Mean − true value shows +2.0 mm. Press Read 5 again: the gap stays. Drag Zero error (worn end) to 0 to remove it.
  2. Under Random error, press Large. The readings spread out and the Range grows, but the mean hardly moves.
  3. The One reading card shows ±0.5 mm, half the ruler's 1 mm least count. The Half the range card is the estimate in the box above.
  4. Choose Stopwatch from the instrument menu. Every time is stopped late: the note under the slider explains that your book calls this a human error, though it acts like a systematic one. One reading now shows ±0.01 s.
  5. Turn on Include an odd reading (number 4). The lab note says what went wrong: a human error. Choose Leave out or Repeat it.

On a phone, the Controls tab under the stage holds the sliders and switches, and the Readings tab holds the cards.

Common mistakes

  • Hoping that more readings will remove a zero error. Averaging helps only with random error; a systematic error stays in every reading until it is corrected.
  • Giving ±0.1 cm as the uncertainty of a metre rule reading. The uncertainty is half the least count, ±0.05 cm.
  • Recording the lower mark when the end of the object has reached or passed the middle of a division. By your book's rule, that reading goes up to the next mark.
  • Forgetting that your book files reaction time with human (personal) errors. Use that name in board answers, even though always stopping late acts like a systematic error.
  • Mixing up the cures: training and digital instruments for human errors, a correction from a more accurate instrument for systematic errors, and the mean of many readings for random errors.
  • Giving an uncertainty for a count. A number found by counting, such as 32 students in a class, is exact.

Exam-style questions

Original questions written in the style of Punjab board exams. Try each one before you reveal the answer.

  1. 1.Errors affect every measurement made in the laboratory.

    1. (a)Name the three types of error described in your textbook.

      3 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Human (personal) errors, systematic errors and random errors.

      Marking points

      • Human (personal) errors
      • Systematic errors
      • Random errors
    2. (b)Give one way of reducing each type of error.

      3 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Human errors: proper training and a careful procedure, or automatic and digital instruments. Systematic errors: compare the instrument with a more accurate one and apply a correction, for example for a zero error. Random errors: take several readings and use their mean.

      Marking points

      • Human: training / careful procedure / automatic or digital instruments
      • Systematic: compare with a more accurate instrument and apply a correction (e.g. allow for the zero error)
      • Random: take several readings and find their mean
    3. (c)Explain why taking the mean of many readings does not remove a systematic error.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: A systematic error pushes all the readings the same way by an equal amount, so their mean is pushed by that amount too. Averaging only cancels the random ups and downs.

      Marking points

      • All the readings are pushed the same way by an equal amount
      • So the mean carries the same shift; averaging reduces only random error
  2. 2.A student measures the length of a pencil with a metre rule marked in millimetres. One end of the pencil is exactly at the zero mark. The other end lies between the 14.3 cm and 14.4 cm marks, just past the midpoint of that division.

    1. (a)State the least count of the metre rule.

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: 1 mm, which is 0.1 cm.

      Marking points

      • 1 mm (0.1 cm)
    2. (b)What length should the student record? Give a reason.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: 14.4 cm. The end has passed the midpoint of the division, so the reading is taken to the next mark.

      Marking points

      • 14.4 cm
      • The end is past the midpoint, so the higher mark is recorded
    3. (c)Write the length together with its uncertainty.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Uncertainty = ½ × least count = ½ × 0.1 cm = ±0.05 cm, so the length is 14.4 ± 0.05 cm.

      Marking points

      • Uncertainty = half the least count = ±0.05 cm
      • 14.4 ± 0.05 cm
  3. 3.The zero end of a metre rule is broken, so the scale cannot be used from its end. A student places one end of a steel rod exactly at the 1.0 cm mark. The other end of the rod is at the 26.7 cm mark.

    1. (a)Find the length of the rod.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Length = 26.7 cm − 1.0 cm = 25.7 cm

      Marking points

      • 26.7 − 1.0
      • 25.7 cm
    2. (b)Explain why the student did not measure from the broken end of the rule.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: The scale no longer starts at the end, so every length read from the end would be wrong by the same amount. This zero error is a systematic error.

      Marking points

      • The rule's zero is missing, so readings taken from the end include a zero error
      • Every reading would be wrong by the same amount: a systematic error
  4. 4.To find the time period of a simple pendulum, a student uses a stopwatch to time 30 complete oscillations. The time is 45.6 s, uncertain by about ±0.3 s because of the student's reaction time.

    1. (a)Calculate the time period of the pendulum.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: T = 45.6 s ÷ 30 = 1.52 s

      Marking points

      • 45.6 ÷ 30
      • 1.52 s
    2. (b)Calculate the uncertainty in the time period.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Uncertainty = 0.3 s ÷ 30 = ±0.01 s

      Marking points

      • 0.3 ÷ 30
      • ±0.01 s
    3. (c)Explain why the student times 30 oscillations instead of one.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: The same starting and stopping error is shared among 30 oscillations, so the uncertainty in one period is 30 times smaller: ±0.01 s instead of ±0.3 s.

      Marking points

      • The reaction-time error is shared among (divided by) 30 oscillations
      • So the uncertainty in one period is much smaller (±0.01 s instead of ±0.3 s)
    4. (d)In your book's terms, what type of error does the student's reaction time cause?

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: Human (personal) error.

      Marking points

      • Human (personal) error

Quick check

6 questions

  1. 1.Which of these is a cause of systematic error?
  2. 2.The least count of a metre rule is 1 mm. What is the uncertainty in a single reading taken with it?
  3. 3.The end of a line lies between the 9.2 cm and 9.3 cm marks and has just passed the midpoint. Which reading should be recorded?
  4. 4.According to your book, what is the best way to reduce human errors?
  5. 5.How is the effect of random errors reduced?
  6. 6.Which of these has no uncertainty at all?