Skip to content

Thermal physics simulation

Thermal Insulation and Cooling Curves Simulation

Compare how fast beakers of hot water cool when wrapped in different materials, with more layers or with a lid. Watch live cooling curves, then run the insulation required practical with realistic readings, repeats and anomalies to spot.

Loading simulation…
Show symbols for

Predict first

Question 1 of 4

An unwrapped beaker of water with no lid starts at 90 °C in a 20 °C room and is left for an hour. Its cooling curve starts steep and then gets flatter. Why does the water cool more slowly later on?

Try this

  1. 1Keep the starting set-up (one bare beaker, then one layer each of newspaper, bubble wrap and cotton wool, all with card lids) and press play. After 10 minutes, which beaker has the biggest drop in the Results table, and which has the smallest? What do the drops tell you about each wrapping?
  2. 2Choose Layers in the Set-up menu beside Record, then press play. Compare the drops for one, two and four layers of cotton wool. Does each doubling halve the drop?
  3. 3Choose Lids in the Set-up menu and press play. Work out how much the card lid changes the drop for the bare beaker, then for the beaker wrapped in cotton wool.
  4. 4Switch Mode to Practical and press play. When the run ends, press Repeat and play again, until you have three runs. Look for a reading marked with a question mark, then check whether the mean drops put the materials in the same order as Model mode does.
  5. 5In Model mode, set Length of run to 60 min, press play and pick the Gradient (tangent) tool on the cooling curves. Measure the rate of cooling near the start and near the end. How do the two rates compare?

On the bench

Up to four identical glass beakers stand on heatproof mats, each holding an equal volume of hot water. For each one you choose a wrapping (nothing, newspaper, bubble wrap, cotton wool, expanded polystyrene or aluminium foil), from one to four layers, and whether it has a card lid. The front of every wrapping is drawn cut away, so you can see the water, tinted from warm orange towards blue as it cools, and the liquid-in-glass thermometer standing in it. Above each thermometer a magnified window shows the scale around the end of the red column. A stopwatch runs in the corner, and one second on screen stands for half a minute of the experiment.

Reading a cooling curve

Each beaker has its own line on the temperature–time graph, and a dashed line marks room temperature. Every curve starts steep and then levels off. Water far above the room passes energy to the air, the bench and the mat quickly; as the gap closes, the transfer slows, so the water creeps towards room temperature without ever going below it. Use the gradient tool to compare the slope early in a run with the slope near the end.

Why wrapping slows the cooling

Energy leaves the water in four ways. It is conducted through the glass, carried off by moving air, given out as infrared radiation and taken away by water that evaporates from the surface. Cotton wool, bubble wrap and polystyrene all hold plenty of still air, which is a very poor conductor, so these materials have a low thermal conductivity. Extra layers make a thicker barrier and a slower transfer, yet even four layers of polystyrene only slow the cooling; they never stop it. Foil works differently: aluminium conducts well, but a shiny surface gives out very little infrared. A lid matters more than most people expect, because the open surface of hot water loses a lot of energy through evaporation.

Doing the required practical

Switch Mode to Practical. Readings go into the results table every minute, to the nearest 0.5 °C, which is how you would read a thermometer marked in whole degrees. Small random errors appear, as they would in a real lab, and in most runs one reading is written down wrongly. The table marks any reading that does not fit the trend, so you can practise spotting anomalies. Press Repeat after each run to collect three sets of results, then compare the mean drops and their uncertainties.

To see the three ways energy moves in more detail, try the conduction, convection and radiation simulation. For why water stores so much energy for each degree, open the specific heat capacity simulation.

Check your understanding

8 questions

  1. 1.Four beakers of water start at 80 °C. After 10 minutes their drops are 9.1, 5.6, 4.7 and 4.3 °C. Which drop belongs to the best insulator?
  2. 2.Why are cotton wool and bubble wrap good thermal insulators?
  3. 3.Why does a cooling curve get less steep as time goes on?
  4. 4.A student compares four wrapping materials. Which of these is a control variable?
  5. 5.What does a card lid mainly do for a beaker of hot water?
  6. 6.A student wraps a beaker in four layers of newspaper instead of two. What happens to the temperature drop in 10 minutes?
  7. 7.While water is cooling, one reading in a results table is 3 °C higher than the readings either side of it. What should the student do?
  8. 8.Aluminium is a good conductor. Why does wrapping a beaker in shiny foil still slow its cooling a little?

For teachers

Embed it in your site or open it full-screen for the projector.

Read more