Skip to content

Waves and sound simulation

Speed of Sound and Echoes Simulation

Time echoes from a wall with a stopwatch, a clapping rhythm or a microphone and timer, and work out the speed of sound. Then use echo times to find the depth of the seabed, the boundaries inside a body and a hidden crack in steel.

Loading simulation…
Show symbols for

Predict first

Question 1 of 4

A microphone and timer show that the echo from a wall 85 m away comes back 0.50 s after a clap. The student walks back until the wall is 170 m away and claps again. How long does the echo take now?

Try this

  1. 1Press Clap. Follow the orange ring out to the wall and the teal echo back to the student, then read the stopwatch. With the wall 85 m away at 15 °C, the Echo time card shows 0.500 s, the time to cover 170 m.
  2. 2Clap four more times without changing anything, waiting each time for the stopwatch to stop, then look at the Results card. The stopwatch readings scatter. Under Timing choose Clap ×20, press Clap ×20 twice and compare the ± value of the new mean with the old one.
  3. 3Before you change anything, work out the echo time for a wall 170 m away, using 340 m/s, and write it down. Then set Distance to the wall to 170 m, choose Mic + timer under Timing, press Clap and compare the timer with your answer. Check the Echo time card (in the Readings tab on smaller screens) only after that.
  4. 4Pick Sonar from the scene menu and press Pulse. Read the fish and seabed echo times on the echo sounder and turn each into a depth with 1500 m/s. Then choose Sonar 1 kHz from the Set-ups menu, press Pulse, choose Ultrasound 50 kHz and pulse again.
  5. 5Pick Scan, choose Steel block and press Pulse. Slide Probe position slowly from 40% to 80%: over the hidden crack an extra echo appears before the far-side echo, which shrinks.

A clap, a wall and a stopwatch

A student claps once in front of a tall wall. The stage draws the sound as an orange ring spreading out from the hands. When it meets the wall, part of it turns round and heads back as a teal ring, as if it came from a second clapper hidden behind the wall. That returning ring is the echo, shown four times slower than real life.

By the time the echo is heard, the sound has crossed the gap twice. If the wall is a distance ss away, the sound covers 2s2s in the echo time tt, so 2s=vt2s = vt and

s=vt2.s = \frac{vt}{2}.

Leaving out the 2 is the most common slip in echo questions. At the start, 85 m from the wall in air at 15 °C, sound moves at 340 m/s and the echo takes 170÷340=0.500170 \div 340 = 0.500 s. Warmer air carries sound slightly faster (v≈331+0.6θv \approx 331 + 0.6\theta with θ\theta in °C, a formula beyond the AQA, Cambridge and Punjab courses).

Why one stopwatch timing is not enough

Whoever holds the stopwatch presses start a moment after the clap and stop a moment after the echo. Each delay is a reaction time of around a fifth of a second, and it changes from press to press, so repeated readings spread out. The strip under the scene marks each late press, and the Results card gives every set of timings a mean, a speed and an uncertainty of half the range.

Here the start and stop delays have the same average, so they cancel on average and only the scatter is left. In real life one press is often later than the other, for example when the clap can be seen coming. That difference is a systematic error: repeating does not remove it, although timing many echoes still shrinks it.

There are two cures. Moving further back makes the echo take longer while the reaction error stays the same size. Better still, clap again each time an echo arrives and time 20 intervals together: the same error is now spread over twenty journeys, and the uncertainty in the speed shrinks to about one per cent or less. Closer than about 17 m, the echo returns in under a tenth of a second and merges with the clap, so a stopwatch cannot time it at all, although the microphone and timer can. (This 0.1 s rule is in the Punjab course; AQA and Cambridge do not ask for it.)

Two microphones, no echo

The two-microphone scene measures the speed of sound without a reflection. A clap passes microphone A, which starts a fast timer, and then microphone B, which stops it. Each microphone hears the sound once, so here v=s÷tv = s \div t with no halving.

Echo sounding at sea

Choose Sonar and a ship sends a short pulse of ultrasound down through sea water at about 1500 m/s. A shoal of fish returns a small early echo and the seabed a larger, later one, and the echo sounder plots both against time. Halve speed × time for each to find its depth; the shallower reflector always answers first.

The Sonar 1 kHz set-up puts the fish 1 m above a seabed 30 m down and sends an audible 1 kHz note instead. A pulse lasts a few cycles, so a low frequency means a long pulse, and the two echoes smear into one. Switch back to 50 kHz and they separate: the wavelength in sea water is only 3 cm, which is why ultrasound picks out finer detail.

Looking inside the body and inside steel

The scan scene puts a probe on the skin or on a steel block. The A-scan shows a spike for each boundary the pulse meets: fat and muscle, both sides of an organ, then bone. Each depth follows from the same rule, using 1540 m/s in soft tissue or about 5900 m/s in steel. Slide the probe across the block and a hidden crack appears as an extra echo before the far side. For the waves themselves, see the sound waves and oscilloscope simulation.

Equations

Check your understanding

8 questions

  1. 1.A student claps 120 m from a cliff and hears the echo 0.70 s later. What value does this give for the speed of sound?
  2. 2.A ship's echo sounder picks up the echo from the seabed 0.60 s after the pulse leaves. Sound travels at 1500 m/s in sea water. How deep is the water?
  3. 3.When an echo time is used to find the distance to a reflector, why is the result divided by 2?
  4. 4.In an ultrasound scan, why does each boundary between tissues send back an echo of its own?
  5. 5.A probe on a steel plate 4.0 cm thick picks up an extra echo that arrives before the echo from the far side. What does this most likely show?
  6. 6.Students time single echoes from a wall with a stopwatch. Which change would best reduce the effect of their reaction time?
  7. 7.Why is ultrasound, rather than an X-ray, normally used to check on a baby before it is born?
  8. 8.Two microphones 1.70 m apart are wired to a fast timer. A sharp clap in line with them gives a reading of 5.0 ms. What is the speed of sound?

For teachers

Embed it in your site or open it full-screen for the projector.

Read more