Skip to content

GCSE Physics — AQA · Particle model of matter

Changes of state

4.3.1.2

Melting, freezing, boiling, evaporating, condensing and sublimating only rearrange the particles, so the mass stays the same. Each is a physical change: reversing it gives back the same substance with the same properties. No equation of its own. Both tiers, GCSE Physics and Combined Science.

Loading simulation…

Symbols match your course. Open the full latent heat and heating curves simulation for more presets and teacher tools.

What AQA asks for: spec point 4.3.1.2

This part of the particle model is for every AQA student: both tiers, Combined Science and GCSE Physics. It has no equation, but density questions often build on it. You should be able to:

  • name the six changes on AQA's list, with the state each starts and ends in
  • describe why mass is conserved when a substance changes state
  • explain why a change of state is a physical change, not a chemical one

Six changes between three states

ChangeFromToEveryday example
Meltingsolidliquidan ice lolly dripping in the sun
Freezingliquidsolidwater setting in an ice-cube tray
Boilingliquidgasa pan bubbling hard on the hob
Evaporatingliquidgaswet washing drying on a line
Condensinggasliquida bathroom mirror misting up
Sublimatingsolidgasdry ice (solid carbon dioxide) vanishing without a puddle

Boiling and evaporating both turn liquid into gas. Evaporation happens only at the surface, and it can happen well below the boiling point. Boiling happens throughout the liquid, with bubbles of vapour forming inside it, and only at the boiling point. Water boils at 100 °C at standard atmospheric pressure; where the air pressure is lower, its boiling point is lower too.

Why the mass does not change

No particles are made or destroyed when a substance changes state. The same atoms or molecules are still there. Only their arrangement, their spacing and their motion are different, so the mass stays the same.

The volume usually does change. Gas particles are far more spread out than liquid ones, so a gas fills much more space. Since density is mass ÷ volume, the same mass in a new volume has a new density.

An open container can look like an exception. As water evaporates from a beaker on a balance, the reading falls, but no mass is destroyed: water particles have simply left the beaker for the air.

Worked example: a bottle in the freezer. A glass bottle holds 0.75 kg of water and is left in a freezer. Water has a density of 1000 kg/m³ and ice about 920 kg/m³. How much more room does the ice need?

Given: the mass is still 0.75 kg after freezing. Equation: recall ρ=mV\rho = \dfrac{m}{V}, so V=mρV = \dfrac{m}{\rho}. Water: V=0.751000=7.5×10−4V = \dfrac{0.75}{1000} = 7.5 \times 10^{-4} m³ (750 cm³). Ice: V=0.75920=8.15×10−4V = \dfrac{0.75}{920} = 8.15 \times 10^{-4} m³ (815 cm³). Answer: about 65 cm³ more, enough to crack the glass. Water is unusual: most substances shrink slightly as they freeze.

Worked explanation: ice in a sealed bag. A sealed bag of ice cubes reads 46.3 g on a balance. An hour later the ice has melted, and the reading is still 46.3 g. Melting only rearranged the particles, and nothing entered or left the bag. Droplets on the outside of the cold bag are condensed water vapour from the room, so wipe them off before weighing.

Physical, not chemical

A change of state is a physical change. No new substance forms, and reversing the change gives back the original material with all of its properties. Refreeze meltwater and you have ice again.

A chemical change makes new substances, and cooling them does not bring back the starting material. A burning candle shows both. Wax near the wick melts, and that liquid sets back into wax when it cools. Some of it turns to vapour, which burns to form carbon dioxide and water. Cooling those will never give you wax.

Using the simulation

In the simulation above, Heating curve begins with 0.50 kg of crushed ice at −20 °C and the heater already set to Heater on. Press Play and the Stage card steps through Ice warms, Ice melts, Water warms, Water boils and Steam warms.

During melting, the Changed state card counts up (for example, 0.25 of 0.50 kg melted) and the particle window reads Pattern breaking up. The total stays 0.50 kg throughout, because the model's container keeps the steam in (see About the model); an open pan would lose mass as steam escaped.

Now choose Cooling curve and press Play. Liquid stearic acid cools until the Stage card reads Freezes, and the graph stays flat at about 69 °C: freezing need not be cold. The solid formed is still stearic acid.

Common mistakes

  • Saying mass is lost when water evaporates from an open dish. The water particles move into the air: the mass leaves the dish, but it is not destroyed.
  • Saying the particles get bigger when a substance melts or boils. Each particle stays the same size; it is the spaces between the particles that change.
  • Mixing up evaporating and boiling. Evaporating happens only at the surface and can happen below the boiling point; boiling happens all through the liquid, at the boiling point.
  • Calling dissolving a change of state. Sugar spreading through tea has dissolved, not melted: it has mixed with the water, and the tea is far too cool to melt sugar.
  • Thinking a change of state is chemical because the substance looks different. Ice, water and steam are one substance; cooling steam gives water, and freezing that water gives ice.
  • Assuming that freezing must be cold. A substance freezes at its own melting point, and stearic acid turns solid at about 69 °C.

Exam-style questions

Original questions written in the style of GCSE AQA. Try each one before you reveal the answer.

  1. 1.A student puts 25 g of ice into a flask, seals it with a bung and places it on a balance. The balance reads 187.4 g. The flask is left in a warm room until all of the ice has melted. The outside of the flask is dried before each reading.

    1. (a)Name the change of state that happens to the ice.

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: Melting

      Marking points

      • Melting (solid to liquid)
    2. (b)State the balance reading after all of the ice has melted.

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: 187.4 g

      Marking points

      • 187.4 g (no change)
    3. (c)Explain your answer to the previous part.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: The flask is sealed, so no particles can get in or out. Melting only rearranges the particles that are already there, so the mass is conserved.

      Marking points

      • No particles / no water enters or leaves the sealed flask.
      • In a change of state the particles are only rearranged (the number of particles is the same), so mass is conserved.
    4. (d)The bung is removed and the flask is heated until some of the water has boiled. The flask is then cooled, the bung is put back in and the flask is weighed again. Explain why the reading is now lower than 187.4 g.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Some of the water turned into steam (water vapour), which escaped into the air through the open neck while the bung was out. Those particles have left the flask, so the mass on the balance is smaller. The mass has not been destroyed.

      Marking points

      • Water boils / turns into steam (a gas) that escapes from the open flask.
      • Particles (and so mass) leave the flask; the mass is not destroyed, it is now in the air.
  2. 2.Changes of state happen in many everyday situations.

    1. (a)Name the change of state in each situation: (i) wet clothes drying on a washing line; (ii) droplets forming on a cold window; (iii) dry ice (solid carbon dioxide) turning straight into a gas.

      3 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: (i) Evaporating (ii) Condensing (iii) Sublimating

      Marking points

      • (i) Evaporating / evaporation
      • (ii) Condensing / condensation
      • (iii) Sublimating / sublimation
    2. (b)Give two differences between boiling and evaporating.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Evaporating happens only at the surface of a liquid, but boiling happens throughout it, with bubbles forming inside. Evaporating happens at temperatures below the boiling point, but boiling happens only at the boiling point.

      Marking points

      • Evaporating happens at the surface only; boiling happens throughout the liquid (bubbles form inside it).
      • Evaporating happens below the boiling point (at any temperature); boiling happens only at the boiling point.
  3. 3.An ice-cube tray holds 0.27 kg of water. The tray is put in a freezer until the water freezes. Density of water = 1000 kg/m³. Density of ice = 920 kg/m³.

    1. (a)State the mass of the ice.

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: 0.27 kg

      Marking points

      • 0.27 kg (mass is conserved)
    2. (b)Give the equation linking density, mass and volume.

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: Density equals mass divided by volume: ρ = m ÷ V

      Marking points

      • density = mass ÷ volume (in words or in symbols)
    3. (c)Calculate the increase in volume when the water freezes. Give your answer in m³.

      4 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Volume of water = 0.27 ÷ 1000 = 2.7 × 10⁻⁴ m³. Volume of ice = 0.27 ÷ 920 = 2.93 × 10⁻⁴ m³. Increase = 2.93 × 10⁻⁴ − 2.7 × 10⁻⁴ = 2.3 × 10⁻⁵ m³

      Marking points

      • Volume of water = 0.27 ÷ 1000 = 2.7 × 10⁻⁴ m³
      • Volume of ice = 0.27 ÷ 920 = 2.93 × 10⁻⁴ m³
      • Subtracting the volume of water from the volume of ice
      • Increase = 2.3 × 10⁻⁵ m³ (accept 2.35 × 10⁻⁵ m³)
    4. (d)Suggest why the tray is not filled right to the top with water.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: The water expands as it freezes, because the same mass of ice takes up a larger volume. A small gap leaves room for the extra volume, so the ice does not overflow or crack the tray.

      Marking points

      • The ice has a larger volume than the water (same mass, lower density).
      • A gap leaves room for the expansion, so the ice does not spill over or split the tray.
  4. 4.When a candle burns, the solid wax near the wick melts. Some of the liquid wax turns to vapour, and the vapour burns in air to form carbon dioxide and water.

    1. (a)Liquid wax runs down the side of the candle and turns solid. Name this change of state.

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: Freezing (solidifying)

      Marking points

      • Freezing (accept solidifying)
    2. (b)Melting the wax is a physical change. Burning the wax vapour is a chemical change. Explain the difference.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Melting makes no new substance: when the liquid wax cools it becomes solid wax again, with its original properties. Burning makes new substances, carbon dioxide and water, which do not turn back into wax when they are cooled.

      Marking points

      • Physical change: no new substance; reversing it (cooling) gives back wax with its original properties.
      • Chemical change: new substances (carbon dioxide and water) form, and cooling does not give back the wax.
    3. (c)Explain why the mass of a burning candle goes down, even though mass is conserved when the wax melts.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: The wax vapour burns, and the products are gases that escape into the air. That mass leaves the candle; it is not destroyed. Melting alone would not change the mass.

      Marking points

      • Wax vapour burns to form gases (carbon dioxide and water vapour) that move away into the air.
      • So mass leaves the candle (it is not destroyed); melting on its own does not change the mass.

Quick check

6 questions

  1. 1.Which change of state turns a solid straight into a gas?
  2. 2.A sealed bag holds 150 g of ice. All of the ice melts. What is the mass of the water in the bag?
  3. 3.Why is melting a physical change?
  4. 4.Which change of state happens when a bathroom mirror mists up?
  5. 5.Which statement is true for evaporation but not for boiling?
  6. 6.Water in an open dish evaporates and the dish gets lighter. What has happened to the missing mass?