The Thermal Insulation Required Practical: Method, Cooling Curves and Results
A step-by-step guide to the thermal insulation practical: packing beakers of hot water with different materials or layers, timing the temperature fall, keeping the test fair and safe, plotting cooling curves, comparing materials by their temperature drop, and improving the method.
Published · 8 min read
On this page
In the thermal insulation practical, you find out which material keeps hot water hot for longest. You put the same volume of hot water into identical beakers, surround each beaker with a different material, and measure how far the temperature falls in the same length of time.
The best insulator gives the smallest temperature drop. It slows down the transfer of energy from the hot water to the cooler room. Always compare the drops, not the final temperatures, because the starting temperatures are rarely exactly the same.
There is a second version of the practical. You keep the material the same and change its thickness, for example by wrapping one, two, three or four layers of newspaper around the beaker.
What are the variables?
- Independent variable: the type of material. In the second version, it is the thickness or the number of layers.
- Dependent variable: the drop in temperature over a fixed time, found with a thermometer and a stopwatch.
- Control variables: the volume of water, its starting temperature (as close as you can), the size and type of beaker, the thickness of each material, the lid, the total time, and where the beakers stand in the room.
Also run one beaker with no insulation. It shows how fast the water cools on its own, so you can see how much each material helps.
What do you need?
| Item | Its job |
|---|---|
| Small beaker inside a larger beaker | The gap between them holds the insulating material |
| Insulating materials | For example cotton wool, bubble wrap, newspaper, felt or polystyrene beads |
| Kettle and measuring cylinder | Heat the water, then measure out the same volume each time |
| Card lid with a hole | Cuts energy lost from the top and holds the thermometer |
| Thermometer or temperature probe | Measures the water temperature |
| Stopwatch | Times the readings at equal intervals |
How do you run the experiment?
- Stand the small beaker inside the large one and pack the gap with the first material. Use the same amount of each material.
- Boil water in a kettle. Measure out a fixed volume, such as 150 cm³, and pour it into the small beaker.
- Put the lid on and push the thermometer through the hole, so the bulb sits in the water without touching the glass.
- When the reading has settled, record the starting temperature and start the stopwatch.
- Record the temperature every 2 minutes for at least 10 minutes.
- Repeat with each other material, and with the empty gap as your no-insulation beaker.
- For the thickness version, wrap the beaker in more and more layers of one material and repeat the same steps.
If you have enough thermometers, run all the beakers side by side at the same time, so they share the same room conditions.
How do you record the results and draw cooling curves?
Use a table with the time in the first column and one column for each material. Put the unit in each heading, such as "time / min" and "temperature / °C", so the cells hold only numbers.
Plot temperature up the side and time along the bottom. Draw a smooth line of best fit through each set of points. These are cooling curves, and you can draw all of them on the same axes.
Each curve is steepest at the start. The water is hottest then, so the difference between the water and the room is largest, and energy leaves fastest. As the water cools, the curve becomes less steep. The best insulator gives the flattest curve. Over just 10 minutes the curves bend only gently, so do not worry if yours look nearly straight. A longer run shows the levelling off much more clearly.
Worked example: comparing four beakers
A class in Birmingham records these temperatures:
| Time / min | No insulation / °C | Newspaper / °C | Bubble wrap / °C | Cotton wool / °C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 80.0 | 79.0 | 83.0 | 80.0 |
| 2 | 76.5 | 76.5 | 81.0 | 78.5 |
| 4 | 73.0 | 74.5 | 79.0 | 77.0 |
| 6 | 70.0 | 72.5 | 77.5 | 76.0 |
| 8 | 67.0 | 70.5 | 75.5 | 74.5 |
| 10 | 64.5 | 68.5 | 74.0 | 73.5 |
Step 1, temperature drop = start − end:
- No insulation: °C
- Newspaper: °C
- Bubble wrap: °C
- Cotton wool: °C
Step 2, average rate of cooling = drop ÷ time: 1.55, 1.05, 0.90 and 0.65 °C per minute.
Step 3, rank the materials: cotton wool is the best insulator here, then bubble wrap, then newspaper.
The trap: bubble wrap ends at the highest temperature, 74.0 °C. That is only because it started 3 to 4 °C hotter than the others. Its drop, 9.0 °C, is larger than the cotton wool's. A hotter start also makes water cool slightly faster, so the fairest fix is to start every beaker at the same temperature (see the improvements below).
Conclusion: cotton wool cut the cooling rate from 1.55 to 0.65 °C per minute, to less than half. Its fibres hold a lot of air still in tiny pockets. Air is a poor conductor, and air held still in this way cannot set up convection currents.
What happens when you change the thickness?
In a typical thickness run, the drop over 10 minutes gets smaller with each extra layer. For example, 15.5 °C with no layers, 12.5 °C with one, 10.5 °C with two, 9.5 °C with three and 9.0 °C with four. Each extra layer helps, but by less than the one before: the drop shrinks by 3.0, then 2.0, then 1.0, then 0.5 °C.
The same idea applies to buildings. A house cools more slowly when its walls are thicker, or when they are built from materials that conduct poorly. Our guide to thermal insulation at home follows this into lofts, walls and windows.
What are the common errors, and how can you improve the method?
- Different starting temperatures. Compare temperature drops. Better still, start the stopwatch for every beaker when its water has cooled to the same temperature, such as 75 °C.
- Different amounts of material. Use equal thicknesses, or weigh out equal masses.
- No lid, or different lids. Much of the energy escapes from an open top, which can hide the differences between materials.
- Reading the thermometer at an angle. Keep your eye level with the top of the liquid column. A temperature probe and data logger avoid this. They also read to 0.1 °C and take readings at exactly the right times.
- A draught or a sunny window. Keep every beaker in the same place, away from both.
- One run only. Repeat each material and find the mean drop. Repeats show whether your results are repeatable, reduce the effect of random errors and help you spot an anomaly.
How can you explore heat transfer?
Open our thermal insulation and cooling simulation. It starts with four lidded beakers of water at 80 °C: one bare, and one each wrapped in a single layer of newspaper, bubble wrap or cotton wool. Press play and compare the drops in the Results table after 10 minutes. Choose Layers from the Set-up menu for the thickness version, or switch Mode to Practical to collect three runs with realistic readings and anomalies to spot.
To see why some materials conduct so poorly, open the conduction, convection and radiation simulation and choose Conduction. Copper, aluminium, steel and glass rods sit in the same hot block, each with pins stuck on with wax. Copper drops its pins first. Glass is such a poor conductor that the warmth hardly moves along it, which is exactly what makes a material a good insulator.
Common mistakes
- Ranking by final temperature. Use the temperature drop, or the average rate of cooling.
- Calling the dependent variable "heat". You measure the temperature of the water.
- Leaving out the no-insulation beaker. Without it, you cannot tell how much each material helped.
- Joining each point to the next with a ruler. A cooling curve is a single smooth best-fit line for each material.
- Saying insulation stops energy transfer. It only slows it down.
Key points
- Same volume of hot water, same beakers, same lid, same time. Only the material, or its thickness, changes.
- The best insulator gives the smallest temperature drop and the flattest cooling curve.
- Cooling is fastest at the start, when the water is hottest compared with the room.
- Compare drops, not final temperatures, unless every beaker started at the same temperature.
- Good insulators hold air still in small pockets. Still air conducts poorly and carries no convection currents.