Aim
To compare how well different materials work as thermal insulators, and to find out how the thickness of an insulating layer affects how quickly hot water cools.
Equipment
- four identical beakers (or small beakers that fit inside larger ones, with the gap packed with the material)
- insulating materials, such as newspaper, bubble wrap and cotton wool
- card lids with a hole for a thermometer
- kettle and measuring cylinder
- four thermometers (or temperature probes and a data logger)
- stopwatch, heatproof mats and elastic bands or tape
Variables
| Type | Comparing materials | Changing the thickness |
|---|---|---|
| Independent | The insulating material | The number of layers of one material |
| Dependent | Fall in temperature over a fixed time | Fall in temperature over a fixed time |
| Control | Volume and starting temperature of the water, the beakers, the lids, the thickness of each material, the time, the place in the room | The same, with one material throughout |
Leave one beaker with no insulation. It is the control: it gives the cooling with nothing round the glass, so you can judge how much each material helps.
Method
- Wrap one layer of a different material round each of three beakers, held with an elastic band. Use the same thickness every time. Leave the fourth beaker bare.
- Boil the water. Measure the same volume, such as 200 cm³, into each beaker with the measuring cylinder.
- Put a lid on every beaker and stand a thermometer in each one through the hole.
- When the readings are close to the starting temperature you chose, write down each one and start the stopwatch.
- Read every thermometer once a minute until the time is up (10, 15 or 20 minutes in the virtual lab). Keep your eye level with the end of the liquid column as you read each one.
- Empty the beakers when the water has cooled, then repeat the whole experiment twice more.
- For the thickness version, wrap the beakers in one, two and three layers of the same material, beside a bare beaker, and follow the same steps.
The virtual lab runs all four beakers side by side. Next reading advances the clock by one minute, and Repeat the experiment starts again with fresh hot water.
Risk assessment
| Hazard | Risk | Control |
|---|---|---|
| Freshly boiled water | Scalds | Fill the beakers where they stand on the mats; never carry a full beaker; cool any scald under cold running water |
| Kettle lead and spilt water | Shock, slipping | Keep the lead away from water and the bench edge; mop spills at once |
| Glass thermometers and beakers | Cuts if they break | Tell the teacher about any breakage and do not pick up the pieces |
Analysing the results
For each beaker, subtract the final reading from the starting reading. This temperature drop over the same fixed time is your measure. The best insulator gives the smallest drop, because it slows the transfer of energy from the water to the room the most. You can also give an average rate of cooling, the drop divided by the time, in °C per minute.
Compare drops, not final temperatures. Two beakers almost never start at exactly the same temperature, and a final reading on its own hides that difference. Every beaker must also be judged over the same length of time: a drop after 10 minutes cannot be compared with a drop after 20.
Find the mean drop for each beaker from your three runs. Half the range of the three drops gives the uncertainty. If the ranges of two materials overlap, your results cannot tell them apart.
Plot temperature against time for all four beakers on one set of axes, with one smooth best-fit curve per beaker. Do not join the dots. Each curve is steepest at the start, when the water is furthest above room temperature, and gets gentler as it cools. The best insulator has the flattest curve.
If one reading sits clearly off its curve, treat it as an anomaly: ring it and leave it out of the curve. If it is a starting or final reading, leave that run's drop out of the mean for that beaker.
Typical results
| Beaker (200 cm³ at 80 °C, lid, 20 minutes) | Typical mean drop / °C |
|---|---|
| No insulation | about 18 |
| Newspaper, one layer | about 12 |
| Bubble wrap, one layer | about 10 |
| Cotton wool, one layer | about 9 |
With more layers of one material the drop gets smaller each time, but each extra layer saves less than the one before. The good insulators all trap air in tiny pockets. Air conducts energy badly, and when it is locked in place it has no room to circulate, so convection is blocked as well.
Evaluation
Resolution. A thermometer marked in whole degrees can be read to about 0.5 °C. A drop of 9 °C then carries an uncertainty of about 6%, so close materials are hard to separate. A longer run gives bigger drops.
Starting temperatures. Hotter water cools faster, so a beaker that starts hotter is at a disadvantage. Start timing each beaker only when its water has cooled to the agreed temperature.
Fair amounts of material. Measure equal thicknesses or weigh equal masses of each material, and wrap them equally tightly.
Surroundings. Keep the beakers together, away from draughts, radiators and sunny windows, so the room affects them all alike.
Better instruments. Temperature probes with a data logger read to 0.1 °C at exactly the right moments and cannot be misread at an angle.
How this practical is examined
Exam-style questions
1. Water in a beaker wrapped in felt starts at 78.5 °C and is at 69.0 °C after 15 minutes. Calculate the temperature drop and the average rate of cooling. (2 marks)
2. Beaker P ends at a higher temperature than beaker Q, but P started 3 °C hotter. A student says P's material is the better insulator. Explain why this conclusion may be wrong. (2 marks)
3. Suggest why a lid is put on every beaker. (2 marks)