Aim
To find the specific heat capacity of a metal block (or of water) by supplying a measured amount of energy with an electric heater and measuring the rise in temperature it causes.
Equipment
- 1 kg block of aluminium or copper with two holes: one for the heater, one for the thermometer
- immersion heater and a low-voltage power supply
- joulemeter (or an ammeter, a voltmeter and a stopwatch)
- thermometer, with a pipette and a little oil or water for its hole
- stopwatch
- insulating jacket or lagging for the block, and a heatproof mat
- top-pan balance, to check the mass of the block
Variables
| Type | Variable |
|---|---|
| Independent | Energy supplied by the heater, read from the joulemeter |
| Dependent | Temperature of the block, and so its rise since the start |
| Control | Mass and material of the block, the insulation round it, the heater, the starting temperature |
Method
- Weigh the block and write down its mass in kilograms.
- Wrap the block in its insulating jacket and stand it on the heatproof mat.
- Use the pipette to put a drop of oil in the thermometer hole, then push the thermometer in.
- Put the heater in the other hole and connect it to the power supply through the joulemeter. Set the joulemeter to zero.
- Write down the starting temperature. Switch on and start the stopwatch at the same moment.
- Every minute, record the joulemeter reading and the thermometer reading in the same row of your table.
- After ten minutes, switch off. The reading keeps rising for a short while, because energy is still spreading out from the metal round the heater. If you work out c from just the start and the end, use the highest reading.
- To measure water instead, put 1.00 kg of water in an insulated beaker, stand the heater in it, and stir gently before each reading.
With an ammeter (in series with the heater) and a voltmeter (across the heater) in place of the joulemeter, find the power from , then the energy supplied by each reading from , with the time in seconds.
In the virtual lab above, each press of Next reading moves the stopwatch on one minute. The table records what you would write down, including the occasional slip of the pen.
Risk assessment
| Hazard | Risk | Control |
|---|---|---|
| Hot heater and block (a copper block can reach about 90 °C) | Burns | Switch on only when the heater is in its hole; leave everything to cool on the mat before you touch it |
| Heater switched on in air | It overheats and can start a fire | Keep it in the block or the water whenever it is on |
| Water or oil near the power supply | Electric shock, slipping | Keep liquids away from the supply; wipe up drips straight away |
| Glass thermometer | Cuts if it breaks | Push it in gently and lay it where it cannot roll off the bench |
Analysing the results
Work out the temperature rise for every row: subtract the starting temperature from each reading. Plot the rise up the side against the energy supplied along the bottom. Leave out the starting point and draw a line of best fit through the readings from one minute onwards.
The equation rearranges to . So the graph should be a straight line, and its gradient is . That means
Worked example. A lagged 1.00 kg aluminium block warms by 28.0 °C over a stretch of the line where the joulemeter counts 26 000 J. The gradient is °C/J, so , or about 930 J/kg °C to two significant figures.
If you plot temperature against time instead, the gradient is , so , with the time in seconds.
The line does not usually pass through the origin. The metal next to the heater warms first, so the thermometer lags a little behind and every reading is slightly low. The line therefore crosses the energy axis just to the right of zero, but its gradient is unchanged. (With no insulation, heat loss bends the points over, so the line through them can pass just above the origin instead.) In the first minute the lag is still building up, which is why that stretch is left out. Without the drop of oil the lag is bigger and lasts longer, so the virtual lab starts its line at two minutes.
A reading that sits well away from the line is an anomaly. Check it, ring it on the graph and leave it out of the line. Never let it pull the line towards itself.
Typical results
| Set-up (1.00 kg, 50 W, 10 minutes) | Typical value from the graph / J/kg °C | Accepted value (rounded) / J/kg °C |
|---|---|---|
| Aluminium, lagged | about 930 | 900 |
| Aluminium, no insulation | about 1020 | 900 |
| Copper, lagged | about 405 | 390 |
| Copper, no insulation | about 450 | 390 |
Repeat runs agree closely with one another, yet every one of them is above the accepted value. The results are precise but not accurate, which is the sign of a systematic error.
Evaluation
Why the value comes out too high. The joulemeter counts all the energy the heater supplies. Part of it escapes into the air, the bench and the mat. That part never raises the block's temperature, so the measured rise is smaller than it should be. Because the rise is what you divide by, a rise that falls short inflates c. The hotter the block gets, the faster it loses energy, so the graph also bends over towards the end.
Insulation. Lagging slows the loss, so the result moves much closer to the accepted value. It never stops the loss completely, so even a lagged block gives a value a few per cent high.
Other sources of error. The heater and the thermometer themselves take in some energy. Poor contact between the thermometer and the metal makes the reading lag and sit too low; the oil fixes this. Each reading also scatters a little at random.
Improvements. Lag the block and put a lid of insulation on top. Use oil in the thermometer hole. Take a reading every minute and use the gradient of a line of best fit rather than one pair of readings. Repeat the whole run with the block cooled back to room temperature, and quote the mean, using half the range for the uncertainty. For water, heat for longer: its rise is only a few degrees, so the thermometer's resolution matters more.
How this practical is examined
Exam-style questions
1. A student heats a 2.0 kg steel block. The gradient of the graph of temperature rise against energy supplied is 0.0011 °C/J. Calculate the specific heat capacity of steel. (3 marks)
2. The student's answer comes out above the accepted value. Explain this, and give one way to bring it closer. (3 marks)
3. Explain why the student puts a drop of oil in the hole that holds the thermometer. (2 marks)