Punjab Board Class 9 Physics · Work, energy and power
Renewable and non-renewable energy sources
Section 5.4Section 5.5Section 5.6
Fossil fuels, nuclear fuel, dams, the Sun, hot rocks, wind, tides, waves and biofuels all supply useful energy, mostly by spinning a turbine joined to a generator. Renewable sources are restored by nature; fossil and nuclear fuels will run out. Each source has its own advantages and drawbacks.
The learning outcomes judge each source in three ways only: is it renewable, when can it be used, and how does it affect the environment?
How each source gives useful energy (Section 5.4)
Source
How the energy is used
Fossil fuels
burning coal, oil or gas boils water in a boiler; the steam spins a turbine coupled to a generator
Nuclear
uranium nuclei split (fission) in a reactor, and the heat raises steam
Geothermal
water sent down one well to hot rocks returns up another as steam to drive a turbine
Biofuels
biomass (plants, dung, sewage) is burned, or rotted in a digester to give biogas, mostly methane; crop ethanol can replace petrol
Hydroelectric
water stored high has gravitational potential energy; falling, it gains kinetic energy and spins a turbine
Tides
the Moon raises the tides; water held behind a dam at high tide flows out through turbines
Waves
floats such as Salter's duck rock on the waves and drive generators
Wind
moving air turns turbine blades joined to a generator
Solar
black solar panels heat water; solar (photovoltaic) cells change light straight into electrical energy
Apart from solar cells, nearly every source of electricity ends with a spinning turbine driving a generator. A fossil fuel station changes chemical energy to heat, then kinetic energy, then electrical energy.
Renewable and non-renewable sources (Section 5.5)
A renewable source is restored by nature as fast as we use it: every monsoon refills the reservoirs, and the Sun, winds and tides keep returning. Wind, solar, geothermal, tidal, wave and hydroelectric energy all count as renewable.
A non-renewable source is a fixed store; whatever we use is gone for good. Coal, oil and gas are remains of living things, changed underground over millions of years, and uranium comes from deposits that will one day be exhausted.
Advantages and disadvantages (Section 5.6)
Source
When can it be used?
Effect on the environment
Fossil fuels
any time, while supplies last
smoke; carbon dioxide warms the climate
Nuclear
day and night
no smoke, but radioactive waste and a risk of leaks
Hydroelectric
while the reservoir holds water
floods land; can waterlog nearby fields
Solar
daytime only; less when cloudy
no smoke while working; large farms cover land
Wind
only when the wind blows
noise; changes the look of the land
Tides and waves
tides at set times; waves in rough seas
can disturb coasts and sea life
Geothermal
day and night, in a few regions
small amounts of underground gases
Biofuels
whenever stored fuel is at hand
smoke (little from biogas) and carbon dioxide when burned
Worked comparison: a village in Cholistan
Question: a village in the Cholistan desert has no grid connection. Compare solar cells and a biogas plant for it.
Renewable? Both, while the herds keep supplying dung for the digester.
When available? Solar cells work only in daylight, so batteries are needed at night; biogas can be stored and burned at any hour.
Environment: solar cells give no smoke while working; biogas gives off carbon dioxide but far less smoke than wood or dung cakes, and leaves slurry for fertiliser.
Conclusion: use both, solar cells by day and biogas for cooking and evenings.
Exploring the sources in the simulation
The simulation above opens on Coal, labelled Non-renewable and tagged "Physics 9, §5.5". Press Play to set the energy moving.
The energy chain reads: chemical energy of the coal, internal (thermal) energy of the steam, kinetic energy of the turbine and generator, then electrical energy.
Choose Hydro, whose chain begins with gravitational potential energy, then press Next for Tidal, Waves, Geothermal and Solar cells.
Press Mix, choose Mostly renewable on a calm day from Examples and press End. In 20 of the 24 hours this model country runs short: still air leaves the turbines idle, and solar cells give nothing in the dark. These are model values, not real data.
Common mistakes
✕Calling nuclear energy renewable because a little fuel gives a lot of energy. Uranium is mined from limited deposits, so it will run out.
✕Writing that solar cells boil water to turn a turbine. Solar cells change light directly into electrical energy; it is solar panels that heat water.
✕Saying that tides are caused by the wind. Tides are raised mainly by the gravitational pull of the Moon; it is winds that make most waves.
✕Leaving the generator out of an answer about a power station. The turbine only spins; the generator joined to it produces the electrical energy.
✕Claiming that renewable sources have no effect at all on the environment. Dams flood land, wind turbines can be noisy and solar farms cover large areas, even though none of them gives out smoke while working.
✕Mixing up 'renewable' with 'always available'. Solar energy is renewable but is not available at night, while coal can be burned at any hour but is non-renewable.
Exam-style questions
Original questions written in the style of Punjab board exams. Try each one before you reveal the answer.
1.Sources of energy are divided into two groups: renewable and non-renewable.
(a)Differentiate between renewable and non-renewable sources of energy.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Renewable sources are replaced by nature as they are used, so they will not run out. Non-renewable sources exist in limited amounts and will run out, because they took millions of years to form or are mined from limited deposits.
Marking points
Renewable: replaced by nature / will not run out
Non-renewable: limited in amount / will run out once used
(b)Give two examples of each type.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Renewable: any two of solar, wind, hydroelectric, geothermal, tidal and wave energy (allow biofuels such as biogas, if new plants are grown to replace those used). Non-renewable: any two of coal, oil, natural gas and nuclear fuel.
Marking points
Two correct renewable sources (allow biofuels if replanted)
Two correct non-renewable sources
(c)Why is nuclear energy counted as a non-renewable source?
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Its fuel, such as uranium, is found in limited amounts and is used up in the reactor.
Marking points
Nuclear fuel (uranium) is limited and gets used up
2.A thermal power station burns coal to generate electricity.
(a)Describe how electricity is produced in this power station. Your answer should mention the boiler, turbine and generator.
4 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Coal is burned and gives out heat. The heat boils water in the boiler, producing high-pressure steam. The steam rotates the turbine, and the turbine drives the generator, so electrical energy is produced.
Marking points
Coal burns, giving heat
Water in the boiler is changed into (high-pressure) steam
Steam rotates the turbine
The generator, turned by the turbine, produces electricity
(b)Write the energy changes in this power station, in order.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Chemical energy of the coal → heat (internal energy of the steam) → kinetic energy of the turbine → electrical energy.
Marking points
Chemical energy → heat
→ kinetic energy → electrical energy
(c)State two harmful effects of burning fossil fuels on the environment.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Burning gives out carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas that increases global warming. It also gives out smoke and other gases that pollute the air and harm health.
Marking points
Carbon dioxide (a greenhouse gas) is given out, increasing global warming
Smoke / harmful gases pollute the air (allow: acid rain, harm to health)
3.Power stations can draw on geothermal energy and on the tides.
(a)How are the rocks deep inside the Earth heated?
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: By energy released inside the Earth, much of it from the decay of radioactive elements.
Marking points
Decay of radioactive elements (radioactive decay)
(b)Explain how electricity is obtained from geothermal energy.
3 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Engineers drill two wells into the hot rocks. Water forced down the first well boils on contact with the rocks, and the steam rises through the second well to spin a turbine connected to a generator.
Marking points
Wells drilled into the hot rocks, with water sent down one of them
The rocks boil the water into steam
Steam returns up the other well and spins a turbine that drives a generator
(c)What causes tides in the sea?
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Mainly the gravitational pull of the Moon on the sea.
Marking points
Gravitational force (pull) of the Moon
(d)Give one advantage and one disadvantage of tidal energy.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Advantage: it is renewable and gives no smoke or carbon dioxide while working. Disadvantage: it can be used only at a few suitable coasts, and the dam changes the habitats of the estuary.
Marking points
Advantage, e.g. renewable / no smoke or carbon dioxide while working / tide times are known in advance
Disadvantage, e.g. only a few suitable sites / harms coastal habitats / power only at certain times / high initial cost
4.Sunlight is put to use with both solar panels and solar cells.
(a)Distinguish between a solar panel and a solar cell.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: A solar panel absorbs heat from the Sun on its black surface and uses it to warm water. A solar cell changes sunlight directly into electrical energy.
Marking points
Solar panel: absorbs the Sun's heat to warm water
Solar cell: changes sunlight directly into electrical energy
(b)Why are many solar cells connected together in a solar cell panel?
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Each cell on its own provides only a tiny voltage; joining many in series adds their voltages up to a usable value.
Marking points
A single cell's voltage is tiny, so joining cells (in series) gives a larger, usable voltage
(c)Solar energy is renewable, but solar cells cannot supply electricity at all times. Explain why, and suggest one way to overcome this.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: There is no sunlight at night, and less on cloudy days. Energy can be stored in batteries during the day, or another source can be used at night.
Marking points
No sunlight at night (less on cloudy days)
Store energy in batteries / use another source at night