Supplement only. Fire alpha particles at thin metal foil and nearly all pass straight through, so the atom is mostly empty space. A few are repelled through large angles, so the nucleus is positive. A very few come back, so the tiny nucleus holds most of the mass.
Gold leaf on temple statues in Myanmar is so thin that light through it looks green, yet it is a few hundred atoms thick. Metal this thin revealed what is inside an atom.
The alpha particle as a probe (Supplement)
An alpha particle is a helium nucleus, two protons and two neutrons, with a relative charge of +2 (its nature is 5.2.2, Core). It is fast and roughly 7300 times as massive as an electron, so electrons hardly turn it. Concentrated positive charge, though, pushes it away hard.
The experiment (Supplement)
A narrow alpha beam meets a very thin metal foil, usually gold, which can be beaten extremely thin.
Thick metal would absorb alpha particles, so the foil must be thin enough for them to cross.
The air is pumped out; otherwise it would absorb the alpha particles.
A detector moves around the foil, counting the alpha particles that leave at each angle.
Beyond the syllabus: Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden did this in 1909 in Ernest Rutherford's Manchester laboratory; Rutherford explained it in 1911.
Worked explanation: three results, three conclusions (Supplement)
Give each result as observation, reason, conclusion; the observation and the conclusion often earn a mark each.
Observation: nearly all the alpha particles go through undeflected, or turn very slightly. Reason: no large force acts on them. Conclusion: the atom is mostly empty space.
Observation: a small number turn through large angles. Reason: they are repelled: both they and the nucleus are positive, and only charge crowded into a small space pushes that hard. Conclusion: the nucleus is positive.
Observation: a very small number return towards the source. Reason: reversing a fast alpha particle takes something far heavier than it. Conclusion: the nucleus holds most of the atom's mass.
Rebounds are rare because so few alpha particles head close to such a tiny target: more evidence that the nucleus is very small.
Why the result was a surprise (beyond the syllabus)
Before 1909 the leading picture was J. J. Thomson's plum pudding model (1904), with positive charge filling the whole atom. Charge spread so thinly could only nudge an alpha particle, so no rebounds were expected.
Worked example: how small is the nucleus? (beyond the syllabus)
A gold atom is roughly 20 000 times as wide as its nucleus (for other elements, 10 000 to 100 000 times). Enlarge the atom until its nucleus is a 3 mm peppercorn.
Diameter of the enlarged atom: 3mm×20000=60000mm.
In metres: 60000÷1000=60m.
The atom becomes a 60 m sphere, longer than an Olympic pool, with one peppercorn at its centre carrying nearly all the mass.
Try it yourself
In the simulation above, the Nuclear model is chosen and Alpha particle energy is 5 MeV.
Press Fire to send 20 000 alpha particles at the gold; the beam then keeps running. Once the screen flashes, Through, under 10° shows close to 99.5%: mostly empty space.
Tap the chart bars for 0° to 10° and past 90°: counts fall steeply with angle, and the ×10 steps scale keeps rare large angles visible.
Press Fire again until Bounced back shows a count. About 1 in 26 000 return here, since the nucleus is so small.
Read What the results show. In the timeline, Rutherford's step is tagged Core (nuclear atom) and Supplement (scattering evidence).
(Beyond the syllabus) On Plum pudding, press Fire: Largest angle stays near 1° and none return. Back on Nuclear, set the energy to 3 MeV (a new count starts). Slower alpha particles turn more easily, and about 1 in 9000 return.
Common mistakes
✕(Supplement) Saying the deflected alpha particles hit the nucleus. They are repelled before they reach it: the push between the two positive charges turns them while they are still some distance away.
✕(Supplement) Explaining the rebounds with electrons. An electron has only about 1/7300 of an alpha particle's mass, far too little to send it back; only the massive nucleus can.
✕(Supplement) Writing 'the alpha particles were repelled, so the nucleus is positive' without the link. State that alpha particles are positive and that like charges repel.
✕(Supplement) Giving only what happened, not what it shows. Each observation needs its conclusion: straight through means mostly empty space; large deflections mean a positive nucleus; rebounds mean the nucleus holds most of the mass.
✕(Supplement) Saying most alpha particles are absorbed or reflected by the foil. Nearly all pass through it; only a tiny fraction are turned back.
✕(Supplement) Thinking a thick sheet of metal would work as well. It would absorb the alpha particles, so the foil must be very thin for them to pass through and be counted.
Exam-style questions
Original questions written in the style of Cambridge IGCSE. Try each one before you reveal the answer.
1.A narrow beam of alpha particles is directed at a thin gold foil in a vacuum. Three possible paths are shown on a diagram. Path A goes straight through the foil. Path B is deflected through a large angle. Path C returns towards the source.
(a)(Supplement) State which path, A, B or C, is followed by the largest number of alpha particles.
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Path A.
Marking points
A
(b)(Supplement) Explain what path A tells you about the structure of the atom.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Most alpha particles meet nothing that exerts a large force on them, so the atom must be mostly empty space.
Marking points
Nothing in the path of most alpha particles deflects them
So the atom is mostly empty space (allow: nucleus very small)
(c)(Supplement) Explain what path B tells you about the charge on the nucleus.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: The nucleus is positive. An alpha particle carries positive charge, and path B shows it being pushed away from the nucleus. Only like charges push each other apart.
Marking points
Alpha particles carry positive charge
Path B shows repulsion; like charges repel, so the nucleus is positive
(d)(Supplement) Explain what path C shows about the mass of the nucleus.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: To reverse a fast alpha particle, the nucleus must be far heavier than it. So the nucleus contains most of the atom's mass.
Marking points
The nucleus is far heavier than an alpha particle
So the nucleus holds most of the atom's mass
2.In a computer model of the scattering experiment, about 1 alpha particle in every 26 000 is deflected through more than 90°.
(a)(Supplement) Explain why such a small fraction of the alpha particles is deflected through more than 90°.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: A nucleus is a tiny target inside a much larger atom, which is mostly empty. Hardly any alpha particles come near enough to a nucleus for the repulsion to send them back.
Marking points
The nucleus is tiny (the atom is mostly empty space)
So hardly any alpha particles come near enough to a nucleus to be sent back
(b)(Supplement) The model is run until 52 000 alpha particles have been detected. Calculate the number expected to be deflected through more than 90°.
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: 52 000 ÷ 26 000 = 2
Marking points
2
(c)(Supplement) Suggest why the metal foil used in the experiment must be very thin.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: A thick sheet of metal would absorb the alpha particles, because they are not very penetrating. With a thin foil, most of them pass through and reach the detector.
Marking points
Thick metal would absorb (stop) the alpha particles / alpha particles have low penetration
So with thin foil (most) alpha particles get through to be detected
3.Before the scattering experiment, many scientists thought that the positive charge and the mass of an atom were spread evenly through its whole volume, with electrons scattered through it.
(a)(Supplement) Suggest what this model predicts for alpha particles fired at a thin metal foil.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: All of them would pass through, turned by only very small angles. None would be deflected through large angles or come back.
Marking points
All (nearly all) pass through with only small deflections
None deflected through large angles / none come back
(b)(Supplement) Explain why this model predicts this.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: With the positive charge thinly spread, the electric push on an alpha particle is never strong enough to turn it much. The electrons are far too light to change its direction noticeably.
Marking points
Charge thinly spread, so the electric push is never strong
Electrons too light (compared with an alpha particle) to deflect it much
(c)(Supplement) Describe the observations that showed this model was wrong, and what they showed about the nucleus.
4 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: A small number of alpha particles turned through large angles. They had been repelled, which shows the nucleus is positive, with its charge crowded into a small space. A very small number returned towards the source, which shows the nucleus also holds most of the atom's mass.
Marking points
A small number turned through large angles
So the nucleus is positive, its charge crowded into a small space (repulsion)
A very small number returned towards the source
So the nucleus holds most of the atom's mass
4.Alpha particles from a radioactive source are used in the scattering experiment.
(a)State the composition of an alpha particle.
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Two protons and two neutrons (a helium nucleus).
Marking points
2 protons and 2 neutrons (allow helium nucleus)
(b)(Supplement) An alpha particle heading straight towards a gold nucleus slows down, stops and then moves back the way it came. Explain why it slows down.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: The alpha particle and the nucleus are both positive, so they repel. The repulsive force acts in the opposite direction to the alpha particle's motion, and it grows as the alpha particle gets closer.
Marking points
Both are positive, so there is a force of repulsion
The force acts against the alpha particle's motion (and increases as it gets closer)