Physics only: spec point 4.8.2
Only GCSE Physics covers red-shift, not Combined Science. Both tiers can be asked about it, and there is no equation. Be ready to:
- explain in words why a receding galaxy's light arrives with a longer wavelength
- say why faster speeds at greater distances mean the universe is expanding, supporting the Big Bang theory
- describe what supernovae have suggested since 1998, and name two open puzzles: dark mass and dark energy
Lines that move
Gases in stars absorb certain exact wavelengths, so a spectrum is crossed by dark lines that identify each element like a fingerprint. Hydrogen's red line, measured in a laboratory, is at 656.3 nm.
In light from most distant galaxies the same patterns appear, but every line has slid to a longer wavelength, towards the red end of the spectrum. That is red-shift. Light's speed stays the same, so the frequency is lower too.
- The galaxy does not turn red; only its lines' positions reveal the shift.
- The pattern stretches as a whole, so the longest-wavelength line moves the most nanometres.
- (Not required by AQA) Approaching galaxies, such as Andromeda, are blue-shifted.
Further away, faster away
Comparing red-shifts with distances, Edwin Hubble published a trend in 1929: the more distant a galaxy, the bigger its red-shift, so the faster it is receding. A stretching universe gives exactly this pattern.
Worked explanation: an elastic cord
Question: marks on an elastic cord lie 1 cm, 2 cm and 3 cm from mark O. In 2 seconds the cord is stretched until every length is 1.5 times as long. Explain how this models galaxies moving apart. (3 marks)
- The marks end up 1.5 cm, 3 cm and 4.5 cm from O, so in the same 2 s they move 0.5 cm, 1 cm and 1.5 cm: three times as far means three times as fast.
- The marks do not crawl along the cord; the cord itself stretches, as space does.
- From any other mark, the rest still move away, the furthest fastest, so no mark is the centre.
Galaxies themselves do not stretch: gravity holds each one together.
From red-shift to the Big Bang
Galaxies moving apart today were once much nearer one another. Trace the expansion back and everything we can see was crowded into a tiny region, extremely hot and dense. According to the Big Bang theory, the universe started like that and has expanded ever since, not as an explosion at one spot but with space stretching everywhere at once.
Scientists built the theory from observations: first a pattern, then an explanation that fits it. It then predicted a faint glow left from the hot early universe, found in the 1960s (beyond AQA). Red-shift is evidence that supports the theory, not proof, and new evidence could still change it.
Since 1998: faster and faster
Gravity pulls galaxies towards one another, so astronomers expected the expansion to be slowing. From 1998, measurements of very distant supernovae pointed the other way: the expansion is speeding up, so far-off galaxies are moving away from us faster and faster.
The unknown cause is called dark energy. Galaxies also spin too fast to be held together by their visible matter alone, suggesting unseen extra mass: AQA's dark mass, usually called dark matter. Neither is understood yet.
Watching red-shift on screen
In the simulation above, the Spectra view lines up laboratory hydrogen with Galaxy D, 300 million light-years away. Galaxies A to K are invented model data.
- Galaxy D's four dark lines all sit to the right of their laboratory partners. Move the measuring cursor onto its Hα line in the close-up: about 670.0 nm, 13.7 nm longer.
- Open Second galaxy to compare and pick Galaxy H, twice as far away. Its Hα line moves 26.3 nm, 1.92 times as far: not exactly double, as the model scatters like real data.
- From the Guided question menu choose Do all lines move equally? (shown as Every line on a phone), predict, then press Show me.
- Press Space, then Stretch. Galaxy 1 goes from 6.0 to 9.0 units away; Galaxy 2, which started twice as far from home, from 12.0 to 18.0. When it stops, tap another galaxy to make it home, then press Again: none approaches home.
Further down, the evidence panel tags red-shift and dark energy AQA 4.8.2; the Speed card, Graph view and microwave background are marked beyond GCSE or AQA.